Maximize Your Profits: Best Cash on Cash Return Investment Properties Near New Haven

Are you ready to unlock the potential of your investment portfolio? Discover the best cash on cash return investment properties near New Haven, where lucrative opportunities await savvy investors. With a thriving real estate market and a growing demand for rental properties, this region offers a unique chance to maximize your returns while minimizing risks. Dive into our comprehensive guide to find out which properties can elevate your investment strategy and lead you to financial success.

New Haven Properties With The Highest Cash on Cash Returns

See Full List of Properties
Id Link Location Type Cash on Cash Price Rent Total Payment NOI Cap Rate Cash Flow GRM DSCR P&I Tax HOA Fees Insurance
88 76 Trumbull St, West Haven, CT 06516 West Haven, CT Single Family 45.7% $215,000 $3,140 $1,503 $3,075 17.2% $1,637 5.7 2.9 $1,056 $382 $0 $65
2 80 Front Ave, West Haven, CT 06516 West Haven, CT Single Family 40.8% $189,000 $2,602 $1,318 $2,545 16.2% $1,284 6.1 2.7 $926 $335 $0 $57
357 525 E Main St TRAILER 46, Branford, CT 06405 Branford, CT Manufactured 37.5% $107,900 $1,974 $1,299 $1,397 15.5% $675 4.6 2.6 $530 $192 $545 $32
372 1423 Quinnipiac Ave UNIT 807, New Haven, CT 06513 New Haven, CT Condo 36.9% $134,000 $1,792 $968 $1,720 15.4% $824 6.2 2.6 $658 $238 $32 $40
196 95 Lenox St APT L, New Haven, CT 06513 New Haven, CT Condo 35.2% $175,000 $2,251 $1,223 $2,198 15.1% $1,028 6.5 2.6 $859 $311 $0 $53
92 25 Donna Dr UNIT A3, New Haven, CT 06513 New Haven, CT Condo 34.4% $74,925 $1,271 $841 $931 14.9% $430 4.9 2.5 $368 $133 $318 $22
101 46 Stevens St, East Haven, CT 06512 East Haven, CT Single Family 34.1% $199,000 $2,520 $1,390 $2,460 14.8% $1,130 6.6 2.5 $977 $353 $0 $60
235 14 Judson Ave, New Haven, CT 06511 New Haven, CT Single Family 33.7% $260,000 $3,262 $1,802 $3,184 14.7% $1,460 6.6 2.5 $1,262 $462 $0 $78
427 119 Kenneth St APT A, East Haven, CT 06512 East Haven, CT Condo 33.4% $110,000 $1,679 $1,067 $1,346 14.7% $612 5.5 2.5 $539 $195 $300 $33
42 240 W Lake Ave, Guilford, CT 06437 Guilford, CT Single Family 32.6% $225,000 $2,795 $1,572 $2,727 14.5% $1,223 6.7 2.5 $1,105 $399 $0 $68

Unlocking Potential: A Unique Investment Opportunity in New Haven

Financial Metrics
  • Cash on Cash Return: 45.68%
  • Cap Rate: 17.16%
  • Net Operating Income: $3,075

Seize the chance to transform an L-shaped lot just a stone's throw from the ocean in the sought-after West Shore neighborhood. This property, while currently condemned, presents a blank canvas for those willing to invest some effort and creativity. With the right vision, you can reconstruct this house into your ideal residence. Please note that the seller has not occupied the property and is offering it in its current state, as-is.

Pros
  • Prime location near the ocean
  • High potential for appreciation with renovation
  • Attractive cash flow metrics
  • Opportunity to customize your dream home
Cons
  • Property is condemned and requires complete rebuilding
  • No existing reports or inspections available
  • As-is sale may deter some buyers

In summary, this property offers a remarkable opportunity for investors and homebuyers alike to create something truly special in New Haven. If you're interested in learning more about this property and other exciting opportunities in the area, please enter your email to stay updated!

Unlock the Potential of This Charming Colonial Fixer-Upper

Financial Metrics
  • Cash on Cash Return: 40.76%
  • Cap Rate: 16.16%
  • Net Operating Income: $2,545

Discover a remarkable chance to transform this Colonial-style residence into your dream home. This 5-room fixer-upper is brimming with potential and awaits your creative touch. The spacious eat-in kitchen, cozy living room, and inviting dining area on the main floor provide a solid foundation for your renovations. Upstairs, you'll find two comfortable bedrooms and a full bath, perfect for family living or guest accommodations. Its prime location offers easy access to Downtown West Haven and New Haven, the University of New Haven, hospitals, the train station, and a variety of shopping and dining options along Boston Post Road. This property is being sold "AS IS," presenting a unique opportunity for savvy investors and homebuyers alike. **Multiple offers are expected, with the highest and best written offers due by Saturday, 10/19/24 at 6:00 p.m.**

Pros
  • High cash on cash return of 40.76%
  • Strong cap rate of 16.16%
  • Spacious layout with potential for customization
  • Conveniently located near essential amenities
  • Opportunity to increase property value through renovations
Cons
  • Requires significant repairs and updates
  • Being sold "AS IS" may deter some buyers
  • Potential for multiple offers may increase competition

In summary, this Colonial fixer-upper is a golden opportunity for those looking to invest in a property with immense potential. Don't miss out on the chance to make it your own! Enter your email to learn more about this property and discover other exciting opportunities in New Haven.

Unlocking the Potential of a Newly Remodeled Gem in New Haven

Financial Metrics
  • Cash on Cash Return: 37.53%
  • Cap Rate: 15.54%
  • Net Operating Income: $1,397

This stunning property, recently renovated just a year ago, boasts a fresh roof, new siding, modern windows, and a complete interior overhaul. With two cozy bedrooms and a full bath equipped with a washer and dryer, it offers both comfort and convenience. Please note that this property is exclusively for owner-occupants, as renting is not permitted. Pet lovers will be pleased to know that pets are allowed with prior approval, making it a welcoming space for furry friends. Prospective buyers should be prepared for a background and credit check before an offer can be accepted.

Pros
  • Recently remodeled with modern amenities
  • High cash on cash return and cap rate
  • Pet-friendly with approval
  • Convenient in-unit laundry facilities
Cons
  • Owner-occupied only; no rental options
  • Background and credit checks required

In summary, this property presents a fantastic opportunity for those looking to invest in a beautifully updated home in New Haven. With impressive financial metrics and a welcoming environment, it’s a chance not to be missed. If you’re interested in learning more about this property and other opportunities in New Haven, please enter your email to stay informed!

Discover the Hidden Gem of New Haven: A Cozy Ranch-Style Condo Awaits

Financial Metrics
  • Cash on Cash Return: 36.90%
  • Cap Rate: 15.40%
  • Net Operating Income: $1,720

Step into this delightful 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom ranch-style condominium that perfectly blends comfort and convenience. Nestled in a prime location, this property offers easy access to public transportation, a variety of dining options, and shopping venues, making it an ideal choice for both investors and homeowners alike.

The layout of the condo is designed for optimal living, featuring spacious rooms that invite natural light and create a warm atmosphere. Whether you're looking to invest or find a cozy place to call home, this property stands out with its attractive financial metrics and desirable location.

Pros
  • Excellent cash on cash return of 36.90%
  • High cap rate of 15.40%
  • Convenient access to transportation and amenities
  • Spacious and inviting interior layout
Cons
  • Limited outdoor space
  • Potential for higher competition in the market

In summary, this charming ranch-style condo in New Haven presents a fantastic opportunity for savvy investors and home seekers. With its impressive financial metrics and prime location, it’s a property worth considering. Don’t miss out on the chance to learn more about this and other properties in New Haven—enter your email to stay updated!

Unlock the Potential of This Charming Townhouse in New Haven

Financial Metrics
  • Cash on Cash Return: 35.25%
  • Cap Rate: 15.07%
  • Net Operating Income: $2,198

This delightful two-level townhouse is a hidden treasure nestled near the scenic Quinnipiac River. With its prime location behind Lenox Street and also accessible via 110 Lexington Ave, this property is perfect for both investors and those looking to occupy. Featuring two spacious bedrooms and one and a half baths, this residence is bathed in natural light, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The serene views from the back are simply breathtaking, making it an ideal retreat after a long day. With only twelve units in the complex, you can enjoy a peaceful living experience that feels exclusive and intimate. This unit is currently vacant and eagerly awaits its new owner!

Pros
  • High cash on cash return of 35.25%
  • Attractive cap rate of 15.07%
  • Abundant natural light throughout the unit
  • Serene views of the surrounding area
  • Small, quiet complex with only twelve units
  • Ready for immediate occupancy
Cons
  • Limited number of units may restrict community amenities
  • Potential for higher competition in the local market

In summary, this townhouse presents a fantastic opportunity for both investors and homebuyers seeking a tranquil living space in New Haven. Don't miss out on the chance to learn more about this property and other exciting opportunities in the area. Enter your email to stay updated!

Unlocking Potential: A Prime Investment in New Haven

Financial Metrics
  • Cash on Cash Return: 34.43%
  • Cap Rate: 14.91%
  • Net Operating Income: $931

This charming one-bedroom condominium presents an exceptional opportunity for both owner-occupants and savvy investors. Nestled conveniently close to major highways, it offers seamless access to the vibrant city life of New Haven. Just a short 10-minute drive from the train station and the prestigious Yale University, this property is perfectly positioned for those who value accessibility and community.

With its attractive financial metrics, this condo stands out as a lucrative investment. The impressive cash on cash return and cap rate indicate a strong potential for profitability, making it an enticing option for anyone looking to expand their real estate portfolio.

Pros
  • Excellent location near major highways and public transport.
  • Close proximity to Yale University, enhancing rental appeal.
  • Strong financial metrics indicating high return potential.
  • Ideal for both personal residence and investment purposes.
Cons
  • Limited space with only one bedroom, which may not suit larger families.
  • Market competition may affect rental rates.

In summary, this property offers a unique blend of location, financial viability, and investment potential. If you're interested in learning more about this opportunity and other properties in New Haven, don't hesitate to enter your email for further information!

Unlocking Potential: A Hidden Gem in New Haven's Coastal Community

Financial Metrics
  • Cash on Cash Return: 34.07%
  • Cap Rate: 14.83%
  • Net Operating Income: $2460

Discover a remarkable opportunity to invest in a property nestled in the charming seaside area of East Haven. This residence, while requiring some renovation, presents a unique chance to create your dream home just two blocks away from the stunning sandy beach, vibrant bocci courts, and a fun splash pad. The surrounding neighborhood boasts well-maintained homes, reflecting a strong sense of community pride. With a little vision and effort, this property can shine brightly once more, making it an ideal choice for those looking to invest in a promising location.

Pros
  • Prime location near the beach and recreational facilities.
  • Strong potential for appreciation with renovations.
  • Community with a focus on property upkeep and pride.
Cons
  • Property is sold in 'AS IS CONDITION'.
  • Not eligible for FHA financing.
  • Requires significant work to restore its former glory.

In summary, this property in East Haven offers a fantastic investment opportunity for those willing to put in the effort to revitalize it. If you're interested in learning more about this property and other exciting opportunities in New Haven, don't hesitate to enter your email for further details!

Unlocking Potential: A Prime Investment Opportunity in New Haven

Financial Metrics
  • Cash on Cash Return: 33.69%
  • Cap Rate: 14.70%
  • Net Operating Income: $3,184

Discover a remarkable investment prospect with this charming single-family residence, currently utilized as a rental property. Nestled in the desirable West River Neighborhood, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home is conveniently located just half a mile from the Yale Bowl and a mere mile from the vibrant downtown New Haven, where an array of restaurants, bars, and shopping awaits. With a current rental income of $2,300 per month, and tenants covering all utilities, this property presents an excellent opportunity for both seasoned investors and those looking to make it their own.

The market rent for updated homes in this area exceeds $2,500, indicating significant potential for increased revenue. Featuring beautiful hardwood floors throughout, this property is not just a house; it’s a canvas for your future. Whether you choose to maintain it as a lucrative income-generating asset or transform it into your dream home, the possibilities are endless. Please note that the property is being sold As-Is, Where-Is, and inspections are for informational purposes only.

Pros
  • Prime location near Yale Bowl and downtown amenities
  • Strong cash flow with current rental income
  • Potential for increased rental income
  • Hardwood floors add charm and appeal
Cons
  • Property sold As-Is, may require updates
  • Current tenants in place, may limit access for viewings

In summary, this property offers a unique blend of investment potential and personal opportunity in the heart of New Haven. Don’t miss out on this chance to explore further! Enter your email to learn more about this property and discover additional opportunities in New Haven.

Unlocking the Potential of a Unique First-Floor Condo in East Haven

Financial Metrics
  • Cash on Cash Return: 33.38%
  • Cap Rate: 14.68%
  • Net Operating Income: $1346

This exceptional one-bedroom ranch-style condo is a rare gem in East Haven, priced attractively under $210,000. With designated parking conveniently located right outside your door, this property offers both accessibility and comfort. The interior boasts a fresh aesthetic, featuring a newly installed vanity, pristine white six-panel doors, elegant wood flooring, and modern windows that enhance the living space. However, it's important to note that these units are not eligible for rental or FHA financing, requiring either a conventional mortgage or cash purchase. Showings are available in the afternoons, accommodating the owner's night shift schedule.

Pros
  • Affordable pricing for a first-floor unit in a desirable area.
  • Convenient parking right at your doorstep.
  • Recently updated features enhance the overall appeal.
  • Strong cash flow potential with impressive financial metrics.
Cons
  • Not eligible for rental, limiting investment options.
  • FHA financing is not available, which may restrict buyer pool.
  • Showings are limited to afternoons due to owner's schedule.

In summary, this first-floor condo in East Haven presents a unique opportunity for savvy investors looking for a well-maintained property with strong financial returns. If you're interested in learning more about this property and other investment opportunities in New Haven, don't hesitate to enter your email for further details!

Unlocking Potential: A Hidden Gem for Investors in New Haven

Financial Metrics
  • Cash on Cash Return: 32.61%
  • Cap Rate: 14.54%
  • Net Operating Income: $2,727

Seize the moment with this remarkable opportunity for both investors and aspiring homeowners! This charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath ranch-style residence, located in the scenic town of Guilford, Connecticut, is primed for transformation after being cherished by the same owner for an impressive 46 years. Spanning over 1,000 square feet, the home boasts a welcoming living area featuring a wood-burning fireplace, ideal for those cozy New England evenings. Step outside onto the deck adjacent to the kitchen, perfect for enjoying meals outdoors during the warmer seasons. The expansive 2-car garage offers generous storage space or the potential for a workshop. With a new roof installed just six years ago, this property is a true diamond in the rough, brimming with possibilities for your creative touch. Don’t let this chance slip away to invest in a property that holds so much promise in a sought-after shoreline community. Please note that the two storage units in the basement are included in the sale, and an old utility trailer in the backyard will also convey as-is, hidden beneath some overgrown foliage.

Pros
  • High cash on cash return of 32.61%
  • Attractive cap rate of 14.54%
  • Spacious living area with a cozy fireplace
  • Large garage for storage or workshop use
  • New roof installed recently
  • Potential for outdoor dining on the deck
Cons
  • Requires renovation and updates
  • Old utility trailer in the backyard may need removal
  • Overgrown landscaping may require attention

In summary, this property presents a unique opportunity for those looking to invest in a home with significant potential in New Haven. If you're interested in learning more about this property and other exciting opportunities in the area, please enter your email to stay updated!